420 Papaloa Rd, Kapaa, Hawaii, 96746, United States
resort comparison guide

Kauai Shores vs Makai Club Resort

Choosing between Kauai Shores Hotel and Makai Club Resort? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next Kauai getaway.

Kauai Shores Hotel resort
Kauai Shores Hotel
All-Ages • Kapaa Oceanfront • Beachfront Dining

Best for families, couples, and value-minded travelers who want a casual oceanfront Kapaa hotel with beachfront dining and a central Royal Coconut Coast base.

Makai Club Resort resort
Makai Club Resort
Princeville • Relaxed Resort • Condo-Style Feel

Better for travelers who want a quieter Princeville resort feel with condo-style space and a more residential North Shore vacation setup.

Quick Verdict: Kauai Shores Hotel vs Makai Club Resort

If you want an all-ages, oceanfront hotel in Kapaa with two outdoor pools, private lanais, free Wi-Fi, included parking through the resort fee, and Lava Lava Beach Club right on the beach, Kauai Shores Hotel is the easier, livelier pick.

If your priority is a quieter Princeville stay with more of a condo-resort rhythm, Makai Club Resort will usually suit travelers who prefer extra independence over a beachfront-hotel atmosphere.

Bottom line: choose Kauai Shores Hotel for beachfront energy, dining, and a convenient east-side base; choose Makai Club Resort for a calmer North Shore-style resort stay with a more residential feel.

Kauai Shores Hotel vs Makai Club Resort – At a Glance

Category Kauai Shores Hotel Makai Club Resort
Overall Vibe Casual, colorful, all-ages oceanfront hotel on Wailua Bay with a lively beachfront restaurant, tropical grounds, and an easygoing Kapaa vacation feel. Relaxed Princeville resort with a quieter, more residential pace that suits travelers who want space, independence, and a less hotel-like stay.
Location On Papaloa Road in Kapaa on Kauai’s Royal Coconut Coast, beside Coconut Marketplace and positioned well for exploring the island by car. In Princeville on Kauai’s North Shore, a better fit for travelers who want that area’s calmer resort setting and do not need to be directly in Kapaa.
Rooms & Suites 200 air-conditioned guest rooms in a two-floor layout, with private lanais or balconies and a straightforward hotel-room setup. More condo-style in feel, making it stronger for guests who value a residential resort stay over a classic beachfront hotel room.
Dining On-site Lava Lava Beach Club serves Hawaiian cuisine, craft cocktails, ocean views, and daily live island music in a casual toes-in-the-sand setting. Better for travelers planning a more self-directed dining routine around Princeville rather than relying on a lively on-site beachfront restaurant.
Pools & Beach Two outdoor freshwater pools, a hot tub, tropical courtyard grounds, and direct oceanfront setting with beach loungers and towels covered by the resort fee. Quieter resort-pool atmosphere in Princeville, better for guests who want a low-key day on property rather than a busier beachfront hotel scene.
Kids & Family All-ages and family-friendly: children are welcome, and children 18 and younger can stay free when using existing bedding. Also best considered for independent family or couple travel where extra space and a calmer resort rhythm matter more than organized hotel-style energy.
Price & Value Best value for travelers who want an oceanfront Kapaa address, included Wi-Fi and parking through the resort fee, bikes, pools, and on-site dining. Best value for travelers who want a quieter Princeville base and a more condo-like vacation style rather than a full beachfront hotel setup.

Rooms & Suites: Oceanfront Hotel Rooms vs Condo-Style Resort Space

Kauai Shores Hotel – Room Style

Rooms at Kauai Shores Hotel are practical, colorful, and hotel-style, with air conditioning and private lanais or balconies across a low-rise two-floor layout.

  • 200 guest rooms with private lanais or balconies
  • Good for couples, families, and friends who want a simple oceanfront home base
  • Free Wi-Fi throughout the hotel, including guest rooms

Kauai Shores Hotel is the better pick if you want a straightforward hotel stay with tropical grounds, pools, and the beach close at hand.

Makai Club Resort – Room Style

Makai Club Resort leans more residential in style, making it a better match for travelers who prefer a condo-resort feel over a traditional hotel-room experience.

  • Better suited to guests who want a more independent vacation rhythm
  • A quieter alternative to a livelier beachfront hotel setting
  • Best for travelers who prioritize a Princeville resort base

If you want a more condo-style stay and are comfortable being away from Kapaa’s beachfront hotel energy, Makai Club Resort has the edge.

Dining & Drinks: Beachfront Restaurant vs Self-Directed Dining

Kauai Shores Hotel – Restaurants & Bars

Dining is a clear strength at Kauai Shores Hotel thanks to Lava Lava Beach Club, the on-site oceanfront restaurant and bar with a casual beachfront atmosphere.

Expect:

  • Fresh Hawaiian cuisine, craft cocktails, and ocean-view dining
  • Breakfast, lunch, happy hour, dinner, and daily live island music
  • A relaxed no-dress-code setting where swimsuits, cover-ups, and bare feet fit the vibe

Makai Club Resort – Restaurants & Bars

Makai Club Resort is better for travelers who prefer to handle dining more independently around Princeville rather than choosing a hotel for its on-site restaurant scene.

  • More self-directed dining style
  • Better for guests who plan meals around their daily North Shore plans
  • Less about a lively beachfront bar-and-restaurant atmosphere

If having an easy oceanfront restaurant and bar on property matters, Kauai Shores Hotel is the stronger dining choice.

Pools & Beach: Wailua Bay Oceanfront vs Quiet Princeville Resort Setting

Kauai Shores Hotel – Pool & Beach Scene

Kauai Shores Hotel sits on a beachfront tropical property with two outdoor freshwater pools and a hot tub, giving guests an easy mix of pool time and oceanfront lounging.

  • Two outdoor freshwater pools on a tropical courtyard and beachfront property
  • Larger pool beside an ocean-view lawn, plus a smaller pool set farther from shore
  • Best for travelers who want casual pool days with beach access close by

Makai Club Resort – Pool & Beach Scene

Makai Club Resort’s appeal is more about a quieter Princeville resort base than a busy toes-in-the-sand hotel scene.

  • Better for guests who want a calmer on-property atmosphere
  • A good fit for travelers focused on the Princeville area
  • Less suited to travelers who specifically want an oceanfront hotel restaurant and lawn scene

If you want the easier beach-and-pool setup with a livelier oceanfront atmosphere, Kauai Shores Hotel is the better match.

Kids & Family: All-Ages Beach Hotel vs Independent Resort Stay

Kauai Shores Hotel – Family Fit

Kauai Shores Hotel is an all-ages property where children are welcome, making it a practical option for families who want a casual beachfront base in Kapaa.

  • Children 18 and younger can stay free when using existing bedding
  • Two pools, beach access, and an easygoing outdoor setting
  • Family-friendly without being limited to families only

Makai Club Resort – Family Fit

Makai Club Resort works best for families, couples, or small groups who are comfortable with a quieter, more independent resort stay in Princeville.

  • Good for travelers who prefer a residential resort feel
  • Better for longer, slower-paced stays than quick hotel-style beach weekends
  • A fit for guests who do not need a lively on-site dining scene

If your family wants beach access, pools, and a restaurant right on property, Kauai Shores Hotel is the simpler choice.

Price & Value: Which Kauai Stay Feels More Worth It?

Kauai Shores Hotel – Value Snapshot

Kauai Shores Hotel offers strong value when you want a central Kapaa location, oceanfront grounds, included Wi-Fi, included parking through the resort fee, and a lively on-site restaurant.

  • Best for travelers who want an oceanfront hotel without a formal luxury-resort feel
  • Great if you value Kapaa access, complimentary bikes, pools, and beach loungers
  • Strong value for guests who will use Lava Lava Beach Club and the Royal Coconut Coast location

Makai Club Resort – Value Snapshot

Makai Club Resort is the better value if your priorities are Princeville, a quieter resort pace, and a more condo-like vacation setup.

  • Best for travelers who want a residential-style resort base
  • Stronger for guests focused on the North Shore area
  • Worth it if you prefer independence over a beachfront hotel restaurant scene

Who Wins? Best Kauai Stay by Travel Style

Best for Beachfront Dining & Kapaa Convenience
Kauai Shores Hotel resort

Kauai Shores Hotel

Choose Kauai Shores Hotel if you want a casual all-ages oceanfront hotel in Kapaa with two pools, a hot tub, beachfront dining, live music, and easy access to the Royal Coconut Coast.

Best for Quiet Princeville Resort Stays
Makai Club Resort resort

Makai Club Resort

Makai Club Resort is the better pick for travelers who want a quieter Princeville resort stay with more of a residential, independent vacation feel.

Best for Casual Pools & Oceanfront Energy
Kauai Shores Hotel resort

Kauai Shores Hotel

For travelers who want beach energy, a restaurant and bar on property, and a central base for exploring Kauai, Kauai Shores Hotel is the more convenient choice.

Best for Independent North Shore Travelers
Makai Club Resort resort

Makai Club Resort

If you want a calmer North Shore setting and do not need the liveliness of an oceanfront Kapaa hotel, Makai Club Resort is the better fit.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Kauai Shores Hotel

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Close